In Road to the Show, complete the new player creation.

While in Road To The Show, on a AA team, participate in a post game interview after being named the Player Of The Game.

While batting, accidentally break your bat.

While batting, reach base on an intentional walk. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game or by switching teams.)

Hit a grand slam. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams.)

Obtain 10 or more hits in a single game. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game or by switching teams.)

Discover the newest member to join the MLB® The Show™ 18 broadcast booth. (This trophy is not awarded in CPU vs. CPU games or if managing a full game in Franchise mode.)

With Pitch Feedback option ON, obtain "Good" pitch timing with the Pulse, Meter, or Pure Analog pitching interface.

Trigger the wrath of a Herald (Solo Campaign only).

Craft 25 recipes (Campaign only).

While driving or leaning out of a vehicle, kill 25 enemies (Campaign only).

Liberate 5 locations from the Project at Eden's Gate (Campaign only).

Follow the clues to the end of 3 treasure hunts (Solo Campaign only).