Complete 'A New Jerusalem'.

Discover the fate of Marko Dragic.

Recover the stash from 4 homesteads.

Reach maximum or minimum Honor level.

Complete Chapter 4.

Complete Chapter 3.

Rob or loot $250.

Reach max bonding level with a horse.

Complete 'Enter, Pursued by a Memory'.

While in Road To The Show, participate in a post game interview after your first MLB® home run.

While in Road To The Show, on a AA team, participate in a post game interview after being named the Player Of The Game.

Discover the newest member to join the MLB® The Show™ 18 broadcast booth. (This trophy is not awarded in CPU vs. CPU games or if managing a full game in Franchise mode.)

In a half inning, strikeout 3 batters in a row. (This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams.)