Barry died

Freed Joseph from the trap

Found 1/2 of the puzzle pieces

Freed Sarah from the trap

Found 1/4 of the Case Files

Freed Henry from the trap

Beat the best time for the Point to Point Minigame (Normal)

Found your first Audio Tape

Found your first Billy Puppet

Beat the best time for the Polarized Circuit Minigame (Normal)

Beat the best time for the Lockpick Minigame (Normal)

Completed the Eye Surgery Minigame

Stomped five Minions to death.