You investigated every item in the game.

You got caught wearing her underwear.

You choose to remain silent whenever possible.

Honesty really is the best policy.

Found all copies of Gangsters Monthly

Found all 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette cards

Took Paulie to a Place of Disrepute

Collected 30 vehicles in the Garage

Resisted arrest by the Lost Heaven Police Department

Lockpicked 5 cars on the streets of Lost Heaven and environs

You might want to double check the evidence...

You got rejected.

Order a fancy coffee.