Equip your first cosmetic item

Qualify from a racing round despite falling over more than 10 times

Complete the Epilogue.

Complete 'Red Dead Redemption'.

Complete 'Goodbye, Dear Friend'.

Complete Chapter 4.

Defeat Osmund Saddler in Separate Ways.

Defeat El Gigante in Separate Ways.

Donate $250 to the gang tithing box.

Complete the main story on Professional mode.

Make it through both minecart sections in the underground tunnel without taking any damage.

Complete the main story on Standard mode or higher.