Play and finish 24 games of at least 3 innings within any mode. (Excludes moments, simulated gameplay, joining game moments in progress.)

Throw out a runner going for extra bases. (Excludes simulated gameplay.)

Have a runner score from first without the baseball leaving the field of play.

As a pitcher, give up a hit on the first at-bat of an inning and then strike out the next batter. (Excludes simulated gameplay.)

Hit a ball that can leave the field on either side of the foul pole.

Strike a batter out by throwing at least 4 different pitches during the same at-bat. (Excludes simulated gameplay.)

Solve 5% of Riddler challenges

Rescue the guards and henchman from the Joker toxin in Decontamination

Complete a combo of 10 moves (any play mode)

Complete a Slayer Gate

Complete chapter "Return"

Complete chapter "We Sing"