You successfully blocked every enemy attack in a single (non-tutorial) battle.

You farted on 10 enemies in the world that were knocked out.

You flung a turd of your own creation at an enemy.

You accepted your fate and chose the name Douchebag yourself.

You collected all Gold, Silver and Bronze trophies in Until Dawn

Ashley or Chris opened the trap door and let the monster in

Mike shot Emily

Chris chose to shoot Ashley

All of the girls survived until dawn

All the boys escaped death

The group found all the clues from the Twins Clueline

Mike allowed Emily to stay in the basement