The Shark - Do not kill the Drug Dealer

Jayden Blues - Play the piano without a wrong note

The Lizard - Cut your finger using axe, knife or pliers + disinfect or cauterize the wound

Nathaniel - Shoot Nathaniel

Listen to all the cocktail trivia.

Conquer Stage 7.

Join the Thieves Guild

Stay in the bar until all the other customers left.

Push 5 blocks at once. (Golden Playhouse)

Conquer Stage 4.

Escape from jail

Select a Standing Stone blessing