Complete story level 1

Unlock all the Pirate Lord characters (Single Player Only)

Unlock all the Jack Sparrow characters (Single Player Only)

Complete a story level without dying (and no invincibility cheat).

Use the Time-Turner

Complete all the Guard Dog levels

Defeat 100 enemies

Fire 100 cannonballs

Play a level in co-op

Use a spyglass

Complete Port Royal in Story without dying

Stand still with no controller input for 5 minutes

Complete "The Flaw in the Plan"