Catch 9 fish. (Catch-22? Great book. Go read it!)

Lose a catch.

Unlock all trophies in Mothmen 1966.

Survive all cryptid waves.

Cry your heart out.

Make a really inaccurate drawing.

Solve the Winans Piece Puzzle.

Lose with 15 or less cards to go.

Make a creature's accurate drawing.

Survive the coyote attack.

Completed an optional ronin mission with the "Midnight" difficulty setting enabled.

Took part in missions with all available allies.